Standing at the rental car counter getting pitched extra insurance coverage is a familiar Sacramento travel experience, and it’s genuinely hard to know in the moment whether you actually need it. Here’s how to figure that out before you’re at the counter.
Does Your Personal Auto Policy Extend to Rental Cars?
In most cases, yes – your personal auto insurance policy typically extends the same coverage you carry on your own vehicle to a rental car, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage if you have them. This means if you already carry full coverage on your own car, you may not need to purchase the rental company’s collision damage waiver.
What to Confirm Before You Rely on This
- Whether your policy specifically extends to rental vehicles, since this can vary by carrier
- Whether your coverage extends to rentals for business purposes, which can sometimes be treated differently
- Whether your coverage extends to international rentals, since this often has different rules
- Your specific deductibles, which would still apply to a rental car claim just as they would to your own vehicle
What Your Personal Policy Typically Doesn’t Cover
- Loss of use fees the rental company charges while the car is being repaired
- Diminished value claims some rental companies pursue after an accident
- Coverage if you don’t carry comprehensive or collision on your own vehicle
Credit Card Rental Coverage
Many credit cards offer secondary rental car coverage as a cardholder benefit, which can help cover gaps your personal policy leaves, like loss of use fees. This coverage is often secondary, meaning it applies after your personal insurance, so it’s worth understanding how the two work together.
When Buying the Rental Company’s Coverage Makes Sense
- You don’t carry comprehensive or collision on your own vehicle
- You’re renting for business purposes and aren’t sure your personal policy extends to that use
- You’re renting internationally, where your personal policy may not apply
- You want to avoid using your own deductible or filing a claim on your personal policy
How to Confirm Your Coverage Before Your Next Trip
Contact your agent before your trip to confirm exactly how your policy handles rental vehicles, including any specific exclusions for business use or international rentals. This is much easier to sort out ahead of time than at the rental counter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need rental car insurance if I have full coverage on my own car?
Often not, since your personal policy typically extends similar coverage to a rental, though it’s worth confirming specifics with your agent.
Does my credit card’s rental coverage replace the need for my own insurance?
Usually not entirely – credit card coverage is often secondary and works alongside your personal policy rather than replacing it.
Should I buy rental coverage for an international trip?
Often worth considering, since personal auto policies frequently don’t extend coverage outside the country.
Confirm Your Rental Car Coverage Before You Travel
Eugene C. Yates Insurance Agency can confirm exactly how your policy handles rental vehicles before your next trip. Contact us today for a quick policy review.

